Meghan Markle’s foray into children’s literature with her debut book, The Bench, has stirred up quite a buzz. While some readers embraced the book as a sweet dedication to her husband and son, many established children’s authors have raised eyebrows, with some arguing that celebrities like Meghan should reconsider their dive into the literary world. In this article, we’ll explore the reception of The Bench, criticisms from the literary community, and the broader debate over celebrities entering the world of children’s books.
Meghan Markle’s The Bench: A Sweet Story with Mixed Reviews
The Inspiration Behind The Bench
Published in 2021, The Bench was Meghan Markle’s first children’s book, reportedly inspired by a Father’s Day poem she wrote for her husband, Prince Harry. The book aimed to capture the bond between father and son as seen through a mother’s eyes, bringing themes of love, family, and connection to young readers.
The story, combined with calming watercolor illustrations by artist Christian Robinson, received some initial praise for its heartfelt theme and tender message. Markle herself described the book as capturing “the warmth, joy, and comfort of the relationship between fathers and sons from all walks of life,” a message she said was close to her heart.
The Reception: Mixed Reactions from Readers and Critics
However, the book’s reception was far from universal acclaim. Some readers and critics found The Bench charming and simple, praising its soft illustrations and cozy theme. Others felt that the book lacked depth and was overly simplistic, with little to engage young readers or their parents. On platforms like Goodreads, reviews were polarized, with some readers calling it “bland” or “lacking in substance.”
Despite these mixed reviews, the book’s release received considerable media coverage, with many focusing on Meghan’s transition from actress to royal to author. But the attention didn’t end with reader reviews—The Bench soon became a topic of heated discussion among established children’s authors, who were less than impressed with Markle’s literary debut.
The Literary Community Speaks Out: “You’re Not Children’s Authors!”
Celebrity vs. Author: The Debate Over Authenticity
The debate over celebrity authorship is nothing new, but Meghan Markle’s entrance into children’s literature sparked renewed conversations. Established children’s authors argued that crafting books for young readers is a skill that requires experience, dedication, and a deep understanding of children’s developmental needs.
The sentiment “You’re not children’s authors!” has resonated across social media and literary circles, with many well-known authors and critics suggesting that celebrity authors may lack the insight and skill necessary for effective children’s literature. Authors with years of experience crafting stories for kids voiced their frustrations, noting that celebrity books often rely on fame rather than quality storytelling.
Views from Established Authors: Is It a Level Playing Field?
One of the key criticisms from established children’s authors is that celebrities like Meghan Markle, who already possess substantial followings, benefit from their fame when publishing books. Experienced children’s authors who work tirelessly to create engaging, educational, and impactful stories often struggle to compete with celebrities who can leverage their public persona to gain instant publicity and shelf space.
Some authors believe that publishers prioritize celebrity books over those by lesser-known authors, affecting the opportunities available for passionate writers who may not have a famous name but bring genuine talent to the table. This uneven playing field, they argue, does a disservice to the children’s literature community and, ultimately, to young readers.
What Makes a Good Children’s Book? Insights from the Experts
Crafting Stories for Young Minds
Experts in children’s literature often emphasize that writing for young readers is about more than creating a cute story; it requires an understanding of child development, language appropriateness, and engaging storytelling techniques. Children’s authors often work to incorporate lessons, humor, and age-appropriate challenges that resonate with young minds.
In contrast, critics argue that The Bench feels more like a personal message than a universally appealing story for kids. They feel that the book may have missed the mark by focusing on Meghan’s personal experiences and relationships rather than crafting an engaging narrative that could captivate young readers.
The Role of Illustrations in Children’s Books
Illustrations play a significant role in children’s literature, providing visual elements that help young readers understand and connect with the story. While The Bench received some praise for Christian Robinson’s gentle watercolor illustrations, some critics felt that the visuals, while beautiful, couldn’t make up for what they saw as weak storytelling.
The combination of storytelling and artwork is essential in children’s literature, and critics argue that while Robinson’s illustrations brought warmth, they couldn’t entirely mask the lack of a compelling narrative.
Meghan Markle and the Trend of Celebrity Authors: Are They Here to Stay?
The Allure of Celebrity Authorship in Children’s Literature
Meghan Markle is far from the first celebrity to enter the world of children’s literature. Other high-profile names like Madonna, Jimmy Fallon, and even Bruce Springsteen have ventured into children’s books, sparking a trend of celebrity-authored stories.
For publishers, celebrity authors bring instant visibility and marketing potential, making them an attractive option. Celebrities, on the other hand, often view children’s books as a way to connect with audiences, share their values, or simply add another accomplishment to their portfolio.
Why Critics Say Celebrities Should Think Twice Before Writing for Kids
The criticism of celebrity authorship isn’t merely about competition; it’s about authenticity. Children’s authors argue that writing for kids is an art form that requires more than star power. Critics suggest that celebrities may underestimate the craft involved and may inadvertently diminish the value of children’s literature by oversimplifying it.
In Meghan’s case, her critics argue that The Bench lacks the engagement factor of books by seasoned children’s authors. While her fame may attract readers, critics worry that these types of celebrity books may fall short of nurturing young readers’ love for literature.
A Look at Other Celebrity-Penned Children’s Books: Hits and Misses
Successful Celebrity Books for Kids
Not all celebrity children’s books receive backlash. Some have been praised for their quality storytelling and positive impact. For instance, former U.S. President Barack Obama’s Of Thee I Sing: A Letter to My Daughters has been praised for its thoughtful message and beautiful illustrations. Similarly, The Wonderful Things You Will Be by Emily Winfield Martin, while not by a celebrity, is an example of a successful book that blends art and a powerful message.
When Celebrity Authorship Falls Short
However, not all celebrity books resonate with young audiences. Critics argue that some celebrity-penned books, while well-intentioned, may feel rushed or overly simplistic. Critics say this could be the case with The Bench, which they argue feels more like a personal project than a universal story for kids.
Meghan Markle’s Perspective: Standing by The Bench
Despite the mixed reviews, Meghan Markle has expressed pride in The Bench and its message. In interviews, she’s spoken about the importance of capturing moments of love and family, and how she hopes the book can inspire similar connections among readers. For her, The Bench is more than just a book—it’s a personal reflection and an offering to families.
In response to critics, supporters argue that Meghan has every right to share her experiences and perspective, just as any other author does. For these fans, The Bench is a heartfelt project that deserves appreciation, even if it doesn’t align with everyone’s taste.
Will Meghan Write Again? The Future of the Sussexes in Literature
With The Bench marking Meghan’s debut in children’s literature, many are curious whether she’ll continue writing. Given her interest in storytelling and connection-building, it’s possible she may explore other genres or further develop her literary skills.
As public figures, both Meghan and Prince Harry have explored various media projects, from documentaries to podcasts. Literature could be another avenue for them to share their values and experiences with the world.